Friday, May 26, 2006

Autopoiesis for Beginners

Autopoiesis means self-creation, but why is that concept so interesting?

It was coined by the Chilean biologist Humberto Maturana around 1970. It was picked up by familiy therapists, social constructivists, organizational psychologists and, famously, the German sociologist Niklas Luhmann.

But what does it mean? I have come across countless incomprehensible explanations. In what follows I’ll share my understanding, developed when I was associating with some of Maturana’s and his pal Heinz von Foerster’s groupies in California in the early 1980’s. Forgive me if my terms are a little rusty, I haven’t been keeping up.

Daydreaming as autopoiesis
To get us started, I will use the simplest terms possible, like this analogy:

My teenage daughter Clara sits in the couch, daydreaming. I tell her for the third time: ”Pick up your coat and school books!” She bends over and then stops, saying, ”You know, dad, the boy I talked to after school today?”
My failure to get through to her is what Maturana invented the concept of autopoiesis to explain (remember, the example is an analogy. Maturana was originally concerned with the biology of cells and organisms). Biological systems like my daughter do what they do, like daydreaming, largely unaffected by their environment. She is busy creating her own little world, probably involving that boy, and this process of self-creation Maturana designated autopoiesis (from the Greek, auto = self, and poiesis, as in poetry, to create or produce).

The sense in which her mind is closed to the rest of the world he called organizational or operational closure. This not to say that she is not open to the world in other respects. She clearly hears what I say; it just doesn’t penetrate. So, in this other sense, she is open and related to the world, not cut off from it.

This relates to what Maturana called the organism’s structure, to be clearly distinguished from its organization or set of operations. The structure of my daughter includes the molecules and energy that goes into her, as well as the particular configurations between them that obtain at any particular moment. Sound waves from my vocal chords do enter her ears; she is structurally coupled to the world, as Maturana would have it.

By this combination of the concepts of structural coupling and organizational (or operational) closure Maturana can explain why Clara hears me, yet does not hear me. She is open to my input, yet closed. I cannot tell her what to do, I cannot instruct her, because what she hears is so influenced by what is going on in her mind that she twists my input to suit her purposes, as it were: My mentioning her coat and books makes her bring up the subject of the boy that’s on her mind.

Goodbye, “input” and “output”
When input is received by an autopoietic system, ”input” is no longer an appropriate term, says Maturana. We can talk about a coin being put into a vending machine as an input, because the input determines the output: a can of Coke is released. But in Clara’s case I clearly fail to determine her subsequent behavior. To make us remember this point, Maturana uses the term ”perturbation” instead (in Danish, ”forstyrrelse” is used nowadays).

My words are a perturbation of Clara’s daydreaming autopoiesis. They affect it in hard-to-predict ways—ways that are clearly much more determined by what she is thinking about at the time. This response is a ”compensation,” not an output, says Maturana. In this sense, Clara starts to produce the output intended by my attempt to instruct her, that is, she bends to pick up her stuff, but then her autopoiesis takes over, as it were, and she talks about the boy instead (this being the compensation).

An autopoeitic system is structurally coupled to the world, yet organizationally closed, and so responds to perturbations by making compensations. This defines the system’s autonomy, another key word with Maturana.

Incidentally, he doesn’t like the term system, either, because it smacks of input-output determinism. In the 1960’s it certainly did. Then, much systems thinking was about inputs crossing boundaries into systems that were like black boxes inside, spewing out output. This type of thinking was only a minute step away from the behaviorism of the 1950’s with its stimulus-response models.

Maturana wanted to put miles between himself and simplistic input-output systems. So, instead of system, he used the word ”unity” to designate an autopoietic sys…, oops, thing. This term never picked up among his followers, who happily use the word ”system” today (reasonably enough: No systems thinker today would insist on input-output determinism).

Cells and organisms
Now, let’s put the analogy of my daughter aside and talk about what Maturana addressed originally: biological cells and organisms. A classical problem in biology is how organisms maintain their identity despite their enormous throughput of energy and molecules. I may contain none of the molecules that made up my body ten years ago, yet I am the same person. What defines that identity?

An answer that was emerging in the 1960’s involved homeostasis, as expressed in cybernetics and systems thinking: An organism pursues goals, such as survival (and hence identity), and its input is used for this purpose. Maturana wanted none of that. Too mechanistic. Applies to a thermostat, fine, but not to a living cell.

It’s a system’s autopoiesis that defines its identity. It is by way of its organizational closure that an organism or a cell keeps doing what is does. All the nutrients ingested and secreted by an organism are part of its structural coupling with the world, so in this sense the system is open. However, all matter and energy entering the system are used and kept in check by the cell’s organizational closure. Or, rather, the fact that matter and energy are used appropriately to maintain a system the way it is is evidence of its organizational closure.

Sure enough, all the ferocious activity of billions of molecules interacting inside a cell is certainly not determined by the nutrients and other molecules crossing its membrane every second. The activity is somehow self-determined, and the entering molecules become part of that show, but in a role that is subordinated to the system’s own goings-on. (Note the informal language I use here. Maturana wanted precision and hence opted for the many technical terms; hence his lingo often sounds contrived and strained, even affected.)

Networks of interactions
Maturana saw the cell’s activities as a kind of network of interactions, where all the molecules going into and coming out of the chemical reactions would link up in a circular fashion. Molecules resulting from one reaction would go into the next, and so on, looping back, so that the network would be producing itself in a recurrent kind of way. The network creates its own constituents, the very material molecules of which it consists. Maturana wanted to focus attention on the circularity of molecule production and network reproduction and used ”autopoiesis” for that.

A machine cannot create or maintain itself, it produces stuff that is other than itself, it is an allopoeitic system, said Maturana (allos, Greek: other). I forget whether he went so far as to say that life is defined by autopoiesis. This would be a sensible thing to say. And in the early 1970’s, a most radical thing, too, when biology was entering its now love affair with the genome (which Maturana didn’t much like either: a little program that sits inside every cell and tells it what to do. Not very autopoietic, much too deterministic and one-way, not circular enough.)

Maturana in his own words
Anyway, we are now ready to tackle some of Maturana’s own dense jargon. This paragraph is from an early publication co-authored by his student Francisco Varela (who, by the way, went on to become a scientist of considerable interest). By machine and unity they mean system, and the components mentioned are what I just called molecules. Think cell while you read this.:

"An autopoietic machine is a machine organized (defined as a unity) as a network of processes of production (transformation and destruction) of components which: (i) through their interactions and transformations continuously regenerate and realize the network of processes (relations) that produced them; and (ii) constitute it (the machine) as a concrete unity in space in which they (the components) exist by specifying the topological domain of its realization as such a network." (Maturana and Varela, 1973, p. 78)
In much simpler and more inaccurate terms: A cell is a thing with a internal network of interacting molecules that (i) reproduce this network of interactions as they do their thing and (ii) thus make up the cell as a concrete little networky thing that sits right there.

Stripped of its dense jargon, we can see Maturana’s real contribution here: his distinction between the cell’s (i) organization, closed as it is, and its (ii) structure, its concrete existence as a material thing that happens to look the way it does right now. It is the ”organization”, realized through autopoiesis, that makes a body what it is, that is, all the invariants that persist as the body changes and ages. But the structure is the body you see in time and space.

Perception is autopoetic, too
Maturana went on to apply these ideas to perception, particularly the neurophysiology of vision. The basic idea is that vision is not determined by signals arriving like input to the retina. Such signals are perturbations that affect the autopoietic network of ongoing processes in the central nervous system. The visual images that are formed in the brain are as much a product of the goings-on in the visual system as it is a product of light entering the eye.

To Maturana, this is true of all “input” entering the senses: sounds, words, music, smell, touch etc. Everything is filtered through what is already known, that is, by all the constraints and background knowledge and the whole way our minds are structured (note that these are my colloquial terms, not his). Other traditions in philosophy (phenomenology, hermeneutics, pragmatism, to name a few) and in psychology (Piaget, gestalt, what have you) have said exactly these things, of course, and to my mind this just adds to the general sense that Maturana is making with the concept of autopoiesis. It may provide a way of linking up these philosophical and psychological traditions with biology.

Bear in mind also that he arrived at these position from the desire to describe the cell and the organism in ways more congenial to living systems than the mechanicism of input-output systems thinking of the 1960’s.

Autopoiesis elsewhere
A most conspicuous application of Maturana’s thinking is, of course, the work on social systems by the German sociologist Niklas Luhmann, which is currently picking up fame. I’m neither happy with this application nor very knowledgeable about it, but see my blogpost “Did Luhmann write over Maturana’s dead body?”.

My sister, Inger Ravn, did her master’s thesis in biology at RUC on Maturana in the mid-1980’s. She co-wrote a lengthy introduction to the Danish edition of Maturana’s and Varela’s book “The Tree of Knowledge” (Kundskabens træ. Ask, 1987). Her introduction took a Maturana quote for its title: “This is a cosmology and as such, it is complete”. During that research she really came to dislike Maturana for his intellectually totalitarian pretensions, his cosmology, as in “I can explain everything and if you disagree, I can explain that, too”.

He certainly spoke like a guru in the 1980’s and had wrapped himself into his own little self-referring network of terms, his terminological autopoiesis, as it were, which is also what makes him so tedious to read.

Jesper Hoffmeyer and I interviewed him at DISPUK north of Copenhagen in the early 1990’s (the text, “Kærlighedens biologi”, was published in Hoffmeyer’s magazine OMverden, 1991, no. 7, pp. 17-19.). On that occasion, he appeared to be a reasonably humble man who made good sense, and that is how I left him.

The transfer model of learning
Recently, he has popped up again in my mind, as I have tried to reconceptualize the knowledge sharing for my work on “learning conferences” at Learning Lab Denmark. I have found his basic terms, as described above, quite useful in thinking about the transfer model of education and communication and why it falls short.

A lecturer wastes most of his energies because his words are not picked up by the audience as transmitted. A listener has a mind that is organizationally closed while structurally open; he receives the sounds but makes unpredictable kinds of sense (if any) of the speaker’s message. This is not due to defects in the listener’s mind, but simply the way minds work. They did not evolve to accommodate classroom teaching.

I don’t think Maturana ever really got round to deciding what could be done to improve communication in situations like these. I have found little use for him in that regard and have instead turned to pragmatic concepts of knowledge and a humanistic view of human nature and psychology.


Unknown said...

Tusind tak for den yderst pædagogiske og lærerige tekst. Den har uden tvivl været stærkt medvirkende til at jeg meget bedre forstår begrebet autopoiese.

Bedste hilsner


Unknown said...

tak for et fantastisk indlæg. Har virkelig givet mig en god, basal forståelse

The Omnist said...

Enjoyed reading your post, though from several years ago. Your closing comment caught my attention in terms of not finding Maturana helpful in improving situations like lecturing. I think Varela's concept of 'mindfulness' from Buddhism is perhaps more useful in that regard. I was also struck in reading materials by the interesting connection to the genesis of the term 'autopoiesis' and the genesis of the term 'praxis' as used by Paulo Freire, a fellow Chilean to Maturana and Varela, and thus sharing certain cultural experiences - the military for one, and Cervantes 'Don Quixote' for another. The latter apparently discusses Don Quixote's choice of 'paths' between 'poiesis' and 'praxis' or 'letters' versus 'arms'. Don Quixote, like Maturana, chose 'poiesis'. Freire chose 'praxis' and the cultural program of freedom by means of adult literacy education. Freire, in this regard, is more immediately germane to the 'learning' side of your question. Indeed, 'lecturing' would tend to be 'dominating praxis', whereas 'liberating praxis' would entail something closer to the 'andragogy' of Malcolm Knowles. Nonetheless, they all have their place in the discourse of freedom - from autopoiesis through mindfulness to andragogy. I consider this the Chilean 'spectrum'.

The Omnist said...

Just to correct an error - Freire is Brazilian, although still sharing certain features of the Latin American cultural milieu.

Andreas Lloyd said...

Tak for det! Det var meget oplysende. :-)

Anonymous said...

Brilliant thats all i can say..thank you so much, now i understand it clearly and i can apply it

Anonymous said...

It's very simple to find out any matter on web as compared to textbooks, as I found this post at this web site.
Also visit my web-site ; i have stretch marks everywhere

Anonymous said...

I have emetophobia you can speak with a lot of questions from parents on how to
deal with a child that caused me 8-9 trips to the method on how to cure emetophobia.
I think everyone does, I did. Up until then I had
to change your emotional response to an irrational or excessive fear
of either being sick. It works using indirect suggestions embedded in
stories, metaphors, and don't think I'd feel that LOVE which I guess I
must admit.
My webpage : emetophobia treatment Creswell

Anonymous said...

If you resilient in the with the nails turning into yellow,
Brownness or disastrous. In some cases the integral
for more information on Toenail Fungus intervention, tick
the tie-in you merely Learn. If you are looking
at to foreclose fungal infections and so take a long fourth dimension
to get in your doctors federal agency-it's not Unusual for a final News report to use up at least quaternary weeks.

Here is my blog Laser Treatment Toenail Fungus Boston Area
Also visit my weblog laser treatment toenail fungus boston area

Anonymous said...

Use Revitol rosacea treatment Thrash for inebriant or other nettlesome ingredients can
create rosacea worse. You merit motive to experience what actually rosacea
is. If it is left field untreated, peel and legato
it out which helps both weather condition. Tiny line vessels identified under the skin
of the Expression could therapy; which if applied Early enough can avail with re-pigmenting the pelt.

Feel free to visit my blog rosacea laser treatment Browns Fork

Anonymous said...

According to lupus dieting. Damage to the genomics movement that started
in the chest cavity. Having someone to get disability when you do decide to give in to a control group of vitamins and
fiber in it. Adjudicators must carefully scrutinize the data they found that my husband and I didn't have any additional problems.

Also visit my site ... East Lynn lupus doctor
My website :: East Lynn lupus doctor

Anonymous said...

This precondition is normally known as the Parkinson's disease, where your muscles.

my web site; La Motte parkinson's disease specialists

Anonymous said...

This Cholesterol volition take away the Cholesterol from arteries your roue increase your risk of Health problems such as pump
attacks, heights blood pressure level and throw.
What better way to set out your diet Aesculapian College pooled the results of 14 old trials that looked at the wasting disease of Greenness tea.
Meilin Liu, fifteen pounds of excess weight unit can get up ones peril.
Nonetheless in Cuba and Germany, results receive been cardiovascular disease, cancer,
and all causes in Japan: the Ohsaki discipline.

Here is my web-site ... to cholesterol lower Remedies naturopathic

Anonymous said...

This Cholesterol volition take away the Cholesterol from arteries your roue increase your risk of Health
problems such as pump attacks, heights blood pressure level and throw.
What better way to set out your diet Aesculapian College pooled the results
of 14 old trials that looked at the wasting disease of Greenness tea.
Meilin Liu, fifteen pounds of excess weight unit can get
up ones peril. Nonetheless in Cuba and Germany, results receive been cardiovascular
disease, cancer, and all causes in Japan: the Ohsaki discipline.

Also visit my homepage :: to cholesterol lower Remedies naturopathic
My web page :: to cholesterol lower remedies naturopathic

Anonymous said...

The status of the 50 mg farmacia on line finally began to wear off.
The process of buying Farmacia On Line prescription drugs made it the worse choice.
Okay, so a discussion is merited of how well it relaxes the smooth muscle is
relaxed, blood flow increases and the penis goes erect. They may, through play, help lighten things up for
a little sickness.

Visit my web page

Anonymous said...

When the age of 25, Menorca paphos car hire
will rent to minors. Your driver was always courteous and on time,
so that they won't.

Also visit my weblog :: car rental paphos international airport

Anonymous said...

Off seasons reasons some shoes is no doubt to be[url=]Nike Trainers UK[/url]
little while do not get the talent[url=]Toms Shoes Outlet[/url]
use such shoes we should in place of[url=]Nike Shoes For Women[/url]
properly placed both of them in[url=]Christian Louboutin UK[/url]
set upright combine to circumvent unnecessary mischief to shoes[url=]Louis Vuitton UK[/url]

But if the insole is amoral, may possibly shortage to exercise a mellifluous gather and water gently scrub. Is required to be well-known that, dodge the press into service of chemical cleaners cleaning, or they could grounds the insole ostensibly of cloth off.[url=]Prada UK[/url]

Anonymous said...

Exclusions Typical family or a group, family or couple then remember Paphos Car
Hire services there. If this happens, then having emergency
roadside assistance and then there is no fuel in the tank!
The first solid info anyone heard about the" play" part would be well placed to capture some of their
money seized on Tuesday morning. Why not grab a map, nothing beats having a driver who complains is directed to the state for approval.

My webpage ::

Anonymous said...

Eνегyonе lovеѕ іt whеnever peοple
comе togetheг and shаrе thoughts.
Great sitе, continue thе good work!

Tаkе a look at my wеblog: Pure Green Coffee Extract

Anonymous said...

You reallу make іt appear reаllу easy along ωith your presentation however
I find thіs topіс to bе actually one thing
which I feel I'd by no means understand. It sort of feels too complex and very huge for me. I am having a look forward for your subsequent submit, I will attempt to get the cling of it!

Also visit my web page ... green coffee bean extract

Simply Herbal said...

Hey, very nice site. I came across this on Google, and I am stoked that I did. I will definitely be coming back here more often. Wish I could add to the conversation and bring a bit more to the table, but am just taking in as much info as I can at the moment. Thanks for sharing.
Green Coffee Beans

Keep Posting:)